In one survey of 3,720 college students, the ones with more ADHD symptoms didn’t hold themselves to higher standards. They held themselves to lower ones, and still judged themselves more harshly for falling short.
That finding explains something I do almost every day. If I can’t do the whole thing, the 20-minute version feels pointless. So I do nothing, or I do everything. Not long ago I made myself a 30-day plan and finished every single task in it in one day.
That’s all or nothing thinking: the sense that anything short of the full version doesn’t count. A lot of us with ADHD know it well. So I went looking for what the research actually says about it, and what I found surprised me.
Key Takeaways
- No study I could find measures all or nothing thinking on its own in adults with ADHD. The closest research looks at harsh self-judgment and thinking patterns more broadly.
- In a large college survey, more ADHD symptoms went with lower standards but a harsher sense of falling short.
- In 112 adults diagnosed with ADHD, the link between distorted thinking and ADHD severity faded once anxiety, mood and personality were taken into account.
- The middle option counts. Naming it before you start helps it feel that way.
What All or Nothing Thinking Looks Like With ADHD
All or nothing thinking is sorting things into two boxes: done all the way, or failed. Therapists also call it black and white thinking.
For a lot of us with ADHD, it shows up around effort. You don’t clean the kitchen because there isn’t time to clean the whole kitchen. You skip the walk because it can’t be a real workout. Or you flip the other way and do the entire plan in one night, because a little bit felt like nothing.

Here’s something I noticed in the search data. Plenty of people search for “all or nothing thinking.” Far fewer search for it alongside ADHD, and questions like “is all or nothing thinking a sign of ADHD” return no data in Google’s keyword tool at all. People are looking for the pattern, not the label.
Honestly, the research looks a lot like that too.
What the Research on ADHD and Perfectionism Actually Found
Lower standards, harsher verdict
In 2023, a team led by Elizabeth Bodalski surveyed 3,720 undergraduates at six public universities in the US. They measured ADHD symptoms and three parts of perfectionism: standards (how high your bar is), order (how much you want things neat), and discrepancy, which is the sense that you’re falling short of your own expectations.
Students with more ADHD symptoms had lower standards and less need for order, but a stronger sense of falling short. The title of the paper says it better than I can: low standards, yet disappointed.
That’s the piece that matches the middle option feeling. The bar isn’t impossibly high. Whatever you do just gets a harsh verdict, so the smaller version doesn’t feel worth starting.
A few honest limits. This was one survey at one point in time, so it shows a link, not a cause. These were college students, almost all 18 to 22, and 71% were women. I’m a man reading that part from the outside, so I hold it loosely.
And adult ADHD symptom checklists are generally built on the DSM-5’s criteria. The DSM-5 is the tool clinicians use, but it isn’t the final word on anyone, and it has a real track record of missing women, people of color and the LGBTQIA+ community.

Is it ADHD, or something traveling with it?
This is where it got more interesting for me. A 2020 study led by Amelia Serine looked at the records of 112 adults diagnosed with ADHD after a full assessment. Once the researchers took anxiety, low mood and personality traits into account, the link between distorted thinking patterns and ADHD severity was no longer statistically significant, as reported in the study’s summary.
So all or nothing thinking may travel alongside ADHD more than it comes from ADHD itself. For some of us, it may show up loudest on anxious or low days.
That’s one clinic’s records, and a result that fades after other factors are counted doesn’t prove there’s no link at all. Diagnoses like these are made against the DSM-5’s criteria, so the same caveat applies: a useful tool, not the final word.

Three Myths About All or Nothing Thinking
Myth: people with ADHD are perfectionists with impossibly high standards. In the Bodalski survey, more symptoms went with lower standards, not higher ones. The pressure came from the verdict, not the bar.
Myth: all or nothing thinking is an ADHD symptom. It isn’t among the diagnostic criteria, and in the Serine study the link faded once anxiety, mood and personality were counted.
Myth: just lower your standards and you’ll feel better. For the students with more symptoms, the standards were already lower. What still stung was the sense of falling short.
The researchers don’t fully agree on what to do with all this. Some clinicians treat thinking patterns like this as part of what keeps avoidance going, and work on them directly. The Serine findings point toward the anxiety or low mood that travels with them. Bodalski’s team points at the harsh self-judgment itself. Nobody has settled which matters most, and I won’t pretend they have.
If you read my post on why some of us work better under pressure, that one was about the load. This one is about the verdict.
How to Make the Middle Option Count
Quick note before the practical part: I’m not a doctor or a licensed mental health professional, and nothing here replaces one. These steps apply what the research found. None of them were tested in these studies.
- Write the middle option down before you start. Write two lines: “The full version” and “The 20-minute version.” Then pick one on purpose. If the harsh verdict lands on the gap, naming the smaller target ahead of time gives it a chance to count. (An application of the Bodalski finding.)
- Decide what “done for today” means. Write one sentence, like “Done means the first drawer is empty.” When that sentence is true, you stop, and you’re done. (An application.)
- Keep a “did” list. Next to your to-do list, write down each partial step as you finish it. Read it before bed. It gives the smaller effort a record the verdict can’t erase. If finishing tends to feel like nothing for you too, my post on why finishing can feel like nothing goes deeper. (An application.)
- Catch the verdict sentence. When you hear yourself think “that doesn’t count,” swap in the plain fact: “I worked on it for 20 minutes.” My conversation with psychologist Joel Schwartz about owning who you are without the shame comes at this from another angle. (An application of the thinking-patterns approach.)
- Check whether it lines up with anxious or low days. For two weeks, put one mark on the calendar on days the all or nothing feeling was strong, and a different mark on days you felt anxious or low. If the marks line up, bring that page to a doctor or mental health professional. (An application of the Serine finding.)
- Ask about therapy aimed at the harsh judgment. Bodalski’s team suggests cognitive behavioral therapy or acceptance and commitment therapy for that harsh self-judgment in particular. That’s their suggestion, not something they tested. If you need a place to start looking, my free Mental Health Resources Hub has options, no email required.

FAQ
Is all or nothing thinking a sign of ADHD?
Not on its own. It isn’t one of the diagnostic criteria, and plenty of people without ADHD think this way too. For some of us with ADHD it’s a very familiar pattern, but it doesn’t diagnose anything.
Why do I either do everything or nothing?
One possible reason from the research I read: a harsh verdict on falling short can make the smaller version feel pointless before it starts. That’s a link researchers measured, not a proven cause. It does match what a lot of us describe.
Is perfectionism an ADHD trait?
Not the way people usually mean it. In the 2023 survey, more ADHD symptoms went with lower standards, not higher ones, plus a harsher sense of falling short. The bar wasn’t the problem. The verdict was.
How do I stop all or nothing thinking?
Start smaller than stopping it. Name the middle option before you begin, and count it when you finish. If the pattern is heavy and constant, a therapist who understands adult ADHD can help you work on it.
Some Is Not None
For a long time I figured finishing a 30-day plan in one day was just how I’m wired. Maybe some of it is. But the research pointed somewhere I didn’t expect. The trouble usually isn’t how high the bar is. It’s how hard we judge ourselves for landing anywhere under it.
The 20-minute version was never nothing. It just never got counted.
If you like digging into this kind of thing with me, I share what I find in my newsletter.
Count the 20 minutes.
Much love. Good vibes. ‐ Ky
Sources
- Bodalski, E. A., Abu-Ramadan, T. M., Hough, C. E., Lefler, E. K., Meinzer, M. C., and Antshel, K. M. (2023). Low standards yet disappointed: ADHD symptoms and experiential avoidance in college students. Journal of Contextual Behavioral Science, 28, 180 to 184.
- Serine, A. D., Rosenfield, B., DiTomasso, R. A., Collins, J. M., Rostain, A. L., and Ramsay, J. R. (2020). The Relationship Between Cognitive Distortions and Adult Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder After Accounting for Comorbidities and Personality Traits. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 44, 967 to 976.


Leave a Reply